Table of Contents

Last Updated: October 14, 2026

What Makes a Good Quality Tequila?

Good quality tequila is a 100% agave spirit, distilled from Blue Weber agave in Jalisco, bottled at full strength, and free from artificial additives and colouring. Everything else, the barrel time, the flavour, the price, is a matter of style and preference.

That definition matters because the shelf is crowded with bottles that look premium and read vaguely.

A quick word on strength. Forty per cent ABV is the standard for full-strength tequila, and it is the point at which agave character carries through a mixer without disappearing. Lower-strength bottles dilute the very thing you are paying for.

How to Read a Tequila Label

The label answers most quality questions before you open the bottle.

  • "100% de agave" means every drop of fermentable sugar came from agave. No exception.
  • "Tequila" alone can legally be a mixto, which allows up to 49% other sugars.
  • Age statement: Blanco, reposado, añejo and extra añejo each describe barrel time, not quality.
  • NOM number: the distillery registration. Same NOM, same producer, whatever the brand name says.
  • Origin: look for the Highlands of Jalisco, where slower-grown agave tends to give rounder, sweeter character.

If a bottle is shy about any of these, that silence is the answer.

100% Agave Tequila vs Mixto

The difference between 100% agave and mixto is the single biggest quality divide in tequila. A mixto ferments agave with added sugar, often from cane, which is cheaper and faster. A 100% agave bottling ferments agave alone, so the flavour has to come from the plant itself.

In practice, mixto tends to taste thinner and sweeter, with the agave pushed to the background. It works in a heavy mixer where everything else is doing the talking. It rarely works neat.

Thiago is 100% Blue Agave Reposado Tequila with natural Mexican flavours. 100% sourced, distilled and bottled in the Highlands of Jalisco at 40% ABV with zero added sugar.

Why Blue Weber Agave Matters

Blue Weber is the only agave permitted for tequila, and it is not a technicality. The plant takes roughly six to eight years to reach maturity, and the Highlands' red volcanic soil and cooler nights push it to grow slower and larger than lowland agave.

Slower growth means more sugars stored in the piña, the heart of the plant. Those sugars become the rounded, gently sweet base that makes a reposado worth sipping.

Pro Tip Turn the bottle around and read the small print before the marketing copy. If it does not say "100% de agave", it is a mixto, however premium the front label looks.

Blanco, Reposado, Añejo: Which Style Suits You?

Style should follow use, not status. Blanco is unaged or briefly rested, reposado sits in oak, añejo and extra añejo sit longer still. None is inherently better; each is built for a different moment.

Blanco (sometimes silver) is bottled young, so the agave leads: green herb, citrus peel, a clean peppery edge.

Reposado rests in oak for between two months and a year.

Añejo spends one to three years in barrel and extra añejo three or more. Both pick up deeper caramel, dried fruit and oak spice, and both are usually sipped slowly rather than mixed.

How Barrel Ageing Actually Changes Flavour

Ageing does three measurable things. First, it softens the alcohol edge through slow oxidation and interaction with the cask. Second, it adds colour, genuine barrel-derived gold, not the caramel colouring some producers add to fake maturity. Third, it layers in wood-derived notes: vanilla, light caramel, baking spice, and at longer ages, dried fruit and leather.

What ageing cannot do is rescue a poor base spirit. A thin mixto aged for two years is still a thin mixto with wood on top. This is why we rest ours for six months in white oak, long enough to round the spirit and add texture, short enough that the Highland agave still leads.

A Quick Style-to-Use Guide

Style Barrel Time Flavour Lead Best For
Blanco 0-2 months Agave, citrus, herb Margaritas, palomas, highballs
Reposado 2 months-1 year Agave with soft vanilla and caramel Sipping over ice, stirred cocktails, gifting
Añejo 1-3 years Caramel, dried fruit, oak spice Slow sipping, after-dinner
Extra Añejo 3+ years Deep wood, leather, dried fruit Special-occasion sipping

If you are buying for a household that drinks both neat and mixed, a reposado covers the most ground. If you are buying to explore, a Thiago minis pack lets you taste three 50ml reposados, Coffee, Vanilla and Black Cherry, before committing to a full bottle.

Thiago Tequila 3 Pack
Thiago Tequila 3 Pack
Thiago Black Cherry Tequila – 70cl
Thiago Black Cherry Tequila – 70cl
Pro Tip Turn the bottle around and read the small print before the marketing copy. If it does not say "100% de agave", it is a mixto, however premium the front label looks. The same back label will usually tell you the age category and the NOM number, the distillery registration, which is the single most useful clue to who actually made the liquid.

The Best Tequila for Sipping Neat or Over Ice

The best tequila for sipping is a 100% agave reposado served at room temperature in a small tulip-shaped glass, or over one large cube if you prefer it colder. Reposado has enough barrel time to soften the alcohol without burying the agave, which is the balance most drinkers are actually looking for.

If you have been put off by a harsh finish before, the culprit is usually a young blanco at high strength, or a mixto with added sugar. A well-made reposado should taste clean and balanced, with a rounded mid-palate and a finish that fades rather than burns.

Thiago Tequila 3 Pack →

A Repeatable Way to Taste Any Tequila

Most roundups tell you what to buy. Fewer tell you how to judge. Here is the method we use at the Thiago team, it works on any bottle, ours included.

  1. Pour a modest measure, around 25ml, into a small glass and let it sit for a minute. The alcohol needs a moment to settle.
  2. Nose it first, from just above the rim. Look for agave (cooked or raw), citrus, and any barrel notes: vanilla, caramel, light spice. Sharp solvent heat usually signals a young or poorly cut spirit.
  3. Take a small sip and hold it. Note the first impression, then the mid-palate, then the finish. A good reposado should move from agave to a rounded middle and end cleanly.
  4. Add a drop of water and taste again. A few drops open the aromatics and reveal whether the base spirit has depth or is simply masked by alcohol.
  5. Score it on four things: aroma, palate, finish, and value for what you paid. That last one matters, a fair reposado will outdrink an over-oaked añejo every time.

Temperature, Glassware and Ice

Room temperature is the default because cold numbs aroma. If you prefer it chilled, use one large cube rather than crushed ice, a single cube chills slowly and dilutes less. A small tulip glass concentrates the aromatics; a tumbler is fine but lets them escape. Avoid chilled glassware straight from the freezer, which flattens the nose.

Thiago Vanilla Tequila – 70cl
Thiago Vanilla Tequila – 70cl

Which Thiago Bottles Suit Sipping

Our Thiago Black Cherry Tequila is bold enough to drink straight with no ice at all, while the Vanilla leans warmer and more rounded. Both sit at 40% ABV, so pour a modest measure and let it open for a minute before the first sip. If you are unsure which flavour suits you, the Thiago minis pack holds three 50ml bottles, Coffee, Vanilla and Black Cherry, which is the sensible way to taste the range before choosing a full bottle.

Key Takeaway For sipping, style beats price. Learn the five-step taste test above and you can judge any bottle on the shelf, not just the ones a roundup tells you to buy.
Watch Out Sip slowly and keep measures modest. For guidance on drinking within sensible limits, see Drinkaware's alcohol advice.

The Best Flavoured Tequila UK Drinkers Should Try

The best flavoured tequila is made by flavouring a genuine 100% agave base with real ingredients, not by adding syrup to a cheap spirit.

We build ours the other way round: 100% Highland Blue Agave Reposado, rested six months in white oak, then enriched with locally sourced fruit, vanilla bean, coffee or tamarind. Zero added sugar, no artificial additives and no colouring.

The range runs to four reposados: Coffee, Vanilla, Black Cherry and Tamarindo Sour, plus an Organico Blanco. A Thiago minis pack holds three 50ml bottles, Coffee, Vanilla and Black Cherry, which is the sensible way to find your favourite before committing to a full bottle.

Bottle Style Flavour Source Best For
Black Cherry 70cl Reposado Locally sourced black cherry Sipping neat, margaritas
Vanilla 70cl Reposado Natural Mexican vanilla bean Mules, sours, over ice
Coffee 70cl Reposado Locally sourced coffee Espresso martinis
Tamarindo Sour 70cl Reposado Locally sourced tamarind Palomas, neat over ice
Minis 3 Pack Reposado Coffee, Vanilla, Black Cherry Gifting, travel, trying the range

Reposado Tequila Cocktails Worth Making at Home

Reposado tequila cocktails work because the barrel time gives the spirit enough body to sit alongside strong mixers. Coffee, vanilla and cherry all pair naturally with citrus, ginger and soda.

Start with a Black Cherry Margarita: 50ml Black Cherry, 25ml fresh lime juice, 15ml agave syrup, shaken hard over ice and strained. The fruit does the work, so keep the syrup light.

The Coffee bottling is the one for an Espresso Martini. Combine 50ml Coffee tequila, 25ml espresso and 15ml coffee liqueur, shake until the tin frosts, then strain into a chilled glass.

Serve all of these responsibly, and keep an eye on measures. For guidance on drinking within sensible limits, see Drinkaware's alcohol advice.

Watch Out Do not shake a carbonated mixer. Build spritzes and mules over ice in the glass, or you will lose the fizz and end up with a flat drink.

Conclusion

The honest answer to what makes a quality tequila is unglamorous: 100% agave, real ingredients, full strength, and a producer willing to tell you exactly where and how it was made.

That is the standard we set for ourselves. Thiago is 100% Blue Agave Reposado Tequila with natural Mexican flavours, sourced, distilled and bottled in the Highlands of Jalisco at 40% ABV with zero added sugar, with no artificial additives and no colouring.

Start with the Thiago minis pack if you want to taste the range before choosing a full bottle, or go straight to the full collection if you already know your flavour.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can you tell if a tequila is good quality?

Check the label for 100% agave, which means no added sugars from other sources. Look for a named region like the Highlands of Jalisco and a stated ABV of 40%. A pale straw-gold colour in a reposado indicates barrel ageing without artificial colouring. Avoid bottles that list syrups or vague flavourings. The best quality tequila tastes clean and balanced, with no harsh burn.

What is the difference between 100% agave tequila and mixto?

100% agave tequila is made entirely from Blue Weber agave, while mixto uses at least 51% agave with the rest coming from other sugars, often cane. Mixto can taste thinner and sweeter. For sipping or premium cocktails, 100% agave is the better choice because the agave character comes through clearly. Check the label: it must state 100% agave, not just tequila.

Is blanco or reposado tequila better for sipping?

Reposado is generally better for sipping because barrel ageing rounds off the edges and adds warmth and depth. Blanco is brighter and more peppery, which suits cocktails. If you want to sip neat or over ice, a reposado rested in white oak for a few months gives a silkier texture. For mixed drinks, either style works well.

What should you look for on a tequila label?

Look for 100% agave, the region of production, the ABV, and the ageing statement. A reposado should state how long it was rested. Avoid terms like gold or joven unless they also say 100% agave, as these can indicate additives. Natural flavourings and no added sugar are worth seeking out if you prefer a cleaner taste.


Most people shopping for a quality tequila are working from incomplete labels and a bad memory of a harsh shot. Choosing well comes down to reading the bottle honestly and tasting against a clear standard. At Thiago, we bottle 100% Blue Agave Reposado from the Highlands of Jalisco at 40% ABV, enriched with real Mexican ingredients and zero added sugar, with complimentary UK delivery on every order. Start with the minis pack and find your favourite.